The Urban Developer
AdvertiseEventsWebinars
Urbanity
Awards
Sign In
Membership
Latest
Menu
Location
Sector
Category
Content
Type
Newsletters
Untitled design (8)
FIRST RELEASE TICKETS ON SALE FOR URBANITY-25 CONNECTING PROPERTY LEADERS ACROSS THE ASIA PACIFIC
FIRST TICKETS ON SALE FOR URBANITY-25 WHERE THE PROPERTY INDUSTRY CONNECTS
SEE DETAILSDETAILS
TheUrbanDeveloper
Follow
About
About Us
Membership
Awards
Events
Webinars
Listings
Partner Lab
Resources
Terms & Conditions
Commenting Policy
Privacy Policy
Republishing Guidelines
Editorial Charter
Complaints Handling Policy
Contact
General Enquiries
Advertise
Contribution Enquiry
Project Submission
Membership Enquiry
Newsletter
Stay up to date and with the latest news, projects, deals and features.
Subscribe
ADVERTISEMENT
SHARE
5
print
Print
OfficeMarisa WikramanayakeTue 21 Feb 23

Council Says No to Melbourne Tower Amendments

Daniel Besen's Phillip Nominees' tower project for 1 Spring Street next to Shell House and Milton House.

The City of Melbourne’s Future Melbourne Committee has refused to support the controversial Spring Street tower in Melbourne’s CBD.

Last year an application was lodged for an amendment to the Melbourne Planning Scheme to allow the 28-storey tower and a plaza to be built. 

It included a gross floor area of 35,804 sq m, 26,023sq m of commercial space, five basement levels and a sky bridge to Shell House. 

Plans for the project were part of an Incorporated Document attached to the amendment.

Daniel Besen and the Roth family are the applicants via the company Phillip Nominees Pty Ltd.

The project also included partial demolition and construction in and around two heritage-listed building—Milton House and the Harry Seidler-designed Shell House.

This triggered two applications to Heritage Victoria in 2022 for separate heritage permission—both were rejected. 

Several revisions to the amendment application and the included plans were made in consultation with planning officers culminating in the Revisions G set of plans. 

The redesigned Tower 2 by Daniel Besen's Phillip Nominees on Spring Street in Melbourne. Source: Phillip Nominees
▲ The redesigned Tower 2 in the Revision G set of plans by Daniel Besen’s Phillip Nominees on Spring Street. Source: Phillip Nominees

In April 2022, the Future Melbourne Committee considered the plans included in Revision G lodged before the council and agreed to support it subject to certain conditions including the reduction of the cantilevered portion of the tower facade to prevent overshadowing of the plaza area.

The matter was then called in by the Victorian planning minister in June 2022 who appointed an Advisory Committee to consider the plans and the amendment. 

That hearing is scheduled for March, 2023. 

“The advisory committee is actually the best way to resolve what is really challenging and complicated proposal,” Councillor Rohan Leppert said.

“Our role here today is to define which aspects of the Melbourne Planning Scheme absolutely needs to be held up but ultimately the minister will make the decision based on the advisory committee thrashing out these issues with all the relevant stakeholders.”

Phillip Nominees were invited to submit amended plans and therefore submitted a Revision J to Amendment C401 to council which did not include any of the approved conditions and changes. 

Planning officers determined that not enough of the plaza space was left open to the sky, that the setbacks were not sufficient, and that the cantilevered affect over Milton House of the tower's facade was reintroduced.

It was also determined that the plans went against design and built form outcomes set out in DDO1 and DDO10 of the planning scheme.

“The tower design is stunning,” deputy lord mayor Nicholas Reece said.

“Because it is located in this Spring Street location which is a publicly accessible private owned square tt has run into a number of very challenging aspects of the planning system which have been set up deliberately to try and protect those precious, publicly accessible spaces.”

City of Melbourne planning officers' recommendation that council refuse to support the Revision J version of the amendment was amended to include a notation that the Revision G version of the plans were supported in April 2022.

This motion was then carried unanimously.

The Victorian planning minister will make the final determination after the advisory committee holds its hearing in March and hears from all stakeholders. 

RetailAustraliaMelbournePlanningPlanningSector
AUTHOR
Marisa Wikramanayake
The Urban Developer
More articles by this author
ADVERTISEMENT
TOP STORIES
Potts Point Coliving EDM
Exclusive

Co-Living Shrugs Off Stigma as Overseas Money Moves In

Clare Burnett
6 Min
Bankstown cbd in Sydney NSW EDM
Exclusive

Breaking Delivery Crisis Chokehold on NSW’s Biggest Housing Market

Vanessa Croll
7 Min
Healthscope Hospital EDM
Exclusive

‘Once-in-a-Decade’ Opportunities Rise in Wake of Healthscope Collapse

Clare Burnett
7 Min
Exclusive

Parking Upsize Threatens Fatal Blow to Project Feasibility

Phil Bartsch
6 Min
One New Zealand Stadium BESIX Watpac
Exclusive

Rising to a Challenge: How BESIX Watpac Topped Australia’s Builders

Clare Burnett
7 Min
View All >
A rendering of the top floors of SP Setia's Atlas skyscraper at 383 La Trobe Street, in Melbourne's CBD.
Residential

SP Setia Flags Changes to 72-Storey Melbourne Skyscraper

Marisa Wikramanayake
Potts Point Coliving EDM
Exclusive

Co-Living Shrugs Off Stigma as Overseas Money Moves In

Clare Burnett
Sponsored

RWC Retail Moves $30m in Regional IGA Sales

Partner Content
The three deals drew more than 1000 enquiries as investor interest in Queensland’s supermarkets runs hot…
LATEST
A rendering of the top floors of SP Setia's Atlas skyscraper at 383 La Trobe Street, in Melbourne's CBD.
Residential

SP Setia Flags Changes to 72-Storey Melbourne Skyscraper

Marisa Wikramanayake
3 Min
Potts Point Coliving EDM
Exclusive

Co-Living Shrugs Off Stigma as Overseas Money Moves In

Clare Burnett
6 Min
Retail

RWC Retail Moves $30m in Regional IGA Sales

Partner Content
2 Min
Brekky Creek Highrise DA Approval hero
Development

Historic Brekky Creek Hotel’s Highrise Neighbour Greenlit

Phil Bartsch
3 Min
View All >
ADVERTISEMENT
Article originally posted at: https://theurbandeveloper.com/articles/spring-street-melbourne-tower-futures-melbourne-refusal