The Urban Developer
AdvertiseEventsWebinars
Urbanity
Awards
Sign In
Membership
Latest
Menu
Location
Sector
Category
Content
Type
Newsletters
TheUrbanDeveloper
Follow
About
About Us
Membership
Awards
Events
Webinars
Listings
Resources
Terms & Conditions
Commenting Policy
Privacy Policy
Republishing Guidelines
Editorial Charter
Complaints Handling Policy
Contact
General Enquiries
Advertise
Contribution Enquiry
Project Submission
Membership Enquiry
Newsletter
Stay up to date and with the latest news, projects, deals and features.
Subscribe
ADVERTISEMENT
SHARE
print
Print
OtherStaff WriterTue 11 Apr 17

Tax Too Blunt To Ease Housing Affordability On Its Own: BDO

iStock-611086620_620x380

Tax advisory firm BDO has called for a holistic approach to tax reform in relation to housing affordability rather than ‘tinkering at the edges’ and changing negative gearing incentives or capital gains tax concessions.

BDO National Tax Leader Marcus Leonard said ahead of delivering the budget in May, Treasurer Morrison is under increased pressure to make changes to solve the housing affordability crisis.

“The temptation is certainly there to tinker with the tax system and try and put downward pressure on rising housing costs,” Mr Leonard said.

“However tax is too blunt an instrument on its own and shouldn’t be the used as the main tool to enact change.

“Tax shouldn’t drive incentives for the investment criteria for residential property and removing or changing taxes and levies charged on housing and development doesn’t solve the problem.”

BDO surveyed 1,215 people on their expectations for the 2017 budget and the need for tax reform had come through strongly in the poll.

“Close to 85% said the Government should reintroduce a broad tax reform process that covers both Federal and State taxes," Mr Leonard said.

“Over 70% of respondents want tax changes to relieve the pressure of housing affordability but generally speaking don’t want those tax changes to be in the form of negative gearing or capital gains discount changes.

“This apparent inconsistency points to the complexity of the factors that contribute to housing affordability. These factors are very broad and, although there may be tax aspects involved, they may be ancillary to the major economic factors of supply and demand."According to BDO's survey, the demand side the factors that restrict housing availability include:

"There may be tax incentives that Federal and/or State Governments could provide to encourage this, such as reductions in payroll tax, land tax, stamp duty and CGT rollover relief for businesses and workers to relocate to such decentralised areas.

“The other major factor restricting supply is the disincentive for home owners to downsize when family members move out. The stamp duty on changing residences is now so high that many people are discouraged from moving to more appropriate accommodation even though their family situation has changed," he said.

"While the best option would be to remove stamp duty completely from residential housing, the provision of stamp duty concessions for older persons when they downsize their houses may have some effect in providing some more supply to the system.

“It is interesting to note that, while negative gearing changes and a reduction in the CGT discount have been rejected by a large majority of poll respondents, these two tax changes would potentially increase the supply of housing for home owners by restricting the demand from investors, and therefore may have some effect on housing affordability," Mr Leonard said.

"However, there is the argument that a reduced demand from investors could reduce the availability of rental accommodation. The counter argument to this is that the number of renters will be reduced as some of them will become home purchasers and thus offset the reduced supply of rental accommodation.”

ResidentialAustraliaFinanceReal EstatePolicyPolicy
AUTHOR
Staff Writer
"TheUrbanDeveloper.com is committed to delivering the latest news, reviews, opinions and insights into the best of urban development from Australia and around the world. "
More articles by this author
ADVERTISEMENT
TOP STORIES
Parallel Workshops Stockdale Housing PBSA project
Exclusive

Suburban Success Story Turns PBSA Thinking on its Head

Leon Della Bosca
7 Min
Exclusive

Interstate Developers Find Lots to Love in ‘Progressive, Affordable’ SA

Taryn Paris
5 Min
Bates Smart Richmond Sportslink HERO
Exclusive

BtR Focus Drives Bates Smart’s Richmond Sportslink Concept

Leon Della Bosca
6 Min
Exclusive

Carparking Correlation: How Parking Fees Provide Office Sector Health Check

Taryn Paris
6 Min
Molti chief Ben Teague out front of 32 Mercer Road Aramadale (rendering)
Exclusive

Buy to the Sound of Cannons: Molti’s Counter-Cyclical Move to Melbourne

Leon Della Bosca
5 Min
View All >
Kangaroo Point Aria Canopy House Revised DA Approval hero
Development

Aria’s Revised Tower Greenlit for Inner-City Kangaroo Point

Phil Bartsch
Third.i Crows Nest Dolls House render EDM
Build-to-Rent

Thirdi Scraps Office Tower for Crows Nest Over-Station Site

Vanessa Croll
Parallel Workshops Stockdale Housing PBSA project
Exclusive

Suburban Success Story Turns PBSA Thinking on its Head

Leon Della Bosca
Top marks for developer’s move from ‘crammed’ city towers to spacious suburban student accommodation…
LATEST
Kangaroo Point Aria Canopy House Revised DA Approval hero
Development

Aria’s Revised Tower Greenlit for Inner-City Kangaroo Point

Phil Bartsch
3 Min
Third.i Crows Nest Dolls House render EDM
Build-to-Rent

Thirdi Scraps Office Tower for Crows Nest Over-Station Site

Vanessa Croll
4 Min
Parallel Workshops Stockdale Housing PBSA project
Exclusive

Suburban Success Story Turns PBSA Thinking on its Head

Leon Della Bosca
7 Min
Warren and Mahoney's rendering of Leftfield's project at 691-693 Burke Road, in Melbourne's Camberwell.
Residential

Leftfield Lifts Cover on 14-Storey Scheme at Camberwell

Marisa Wikramanayake
3 Min
View All >
ADVERTISEMENT
Article originally posted at: https://theurbandeveloper.com/articles/tax-too-blunt-ease-housing-affordability-bdo